Christianity.id
Straight answers

Christianity FAQ: Straight Answers, Tradition Named

Where the answer depends on which tradition you ask, we say what it depends on rather than picking a winner.

Do all Christians believe the same things?

On the core claims formalized in the Nicene Creed — one God in three persons, the incarnation and resurrection of Christ, the coming judgment — most historic Christian traditions agree. Beyond that, Catholic, Orthodox, and the many Protestant traditions differ on questions like the authority of the Pope, the number and meaning of the sacraments, and how salvation works, sometimes sharply.

What's the actual difference between Catholic and Protestant?

Catholic tradition holds that the Pope has final teaching authority and that both Scripture and Church tradition carry authority; most Protestant traditions hold Scripture alone ("sola scriptura") as the final authority and reject the Pope's authority over them. The traditions also differ on the number of sacraments, the nature of the Eucharist, and the role of saints and Mary.

What's the difference between Catholic and Orthodox?

Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Christianity share ancient roots and split formally in the Great Schism of 1054, largely over the authority of the Pope over the whole Church and a theological dispute over the wording of the Nicene Creed (the "filioque" clause). Orthodox churches are organized as autocephalous (self-governing) national churches rather than under one central authority.

Is the Bible one book or many?

It's a collection of separate texts — 66 books in most Protestant Bibles, more in Catholic and Orthodox Bibles, which include additional books often called the deuterocanon or Apocrypha — written across roughly a thousand years by many different authors, later gathered into what's called a canon.

Who decided which books are in the Bible?

The Old Testament canon largely follows the Hebrew Bible; the New Testament canon took shape over the first few centuries of the Church through a combination of widespread early use and formal recognition at regional councils. Catholic and Orthodox Bibles include some additional Old Testament books that most Protestant traditions, following the Reformation-era return to the Hebrew canon, do not.

Do Christians have to go to church?

Catholic and Orthodox teaching hold regular worship attendance (Catholic teaching specifies Sunday Mass) as an obligation of the faith. Most Protestant traditions strongly encourage but don't formally mandate attendance, treating it as a normal expression of a life of faith rather than a rule with a penalty attached.

What do Christians believe happens after death?

Most historic traditions teach some form of resurrection and final judgment, plus an intermediate state. Catholic teaching includes purgatory as a state of purification; Orthodox tradition holds a related but less formally defined view; most Protestant traditions reject purgatory and teach a more direct outcome. Specifics of heaven and hell are debated even within traditions.

Is Christianity anti-science?

Historically and today, Christians span the full range from young-earth creationism to full acceptance of evolutionary biology, often within the same denomination. Catholic and most mainline Protestant and Orthodox teaching officially accept evolutionary science as compatible with faith; some Protestant traditions, particularly in the U.S. evangelical stream, teach a literal six-day creation. There is no single Christian position.

What's the point of the Nicene Creed?

It's a shared statement of core belief, written to settle specific fourth-century disputes about the nature of Christ, that Catholic, Orthodox, and many Protestant churches still recite together in worship. Reciting it is one of the few things that happens, in some form, across nearly the whole tradition.

Can you be Christian without belonging to a church?

Most Christian traditions teach that faith is meant to be lived in community, but views differ on whether church membership is required for salvation itself versus strongly recommended as part of a healthy faith. This is a genuinely contested question across traditions, not one with a single Christian answer.

Why are there so many Protestant denominations specifically?

Because Protestant tradition generally holds that Scripture, not a central authority, has final say, disagreements about how to read Scripture on a given question have tended to produce new denominations rather than being settled by one body. Estimates of the total number of Christian denominations worldwide vary widely by how narrowly "denomination" is defined, but scholarly estimates commonly run into the tens of thousands.

Is this site trying to convert me to something?

No. It describes what different Christian traditions teach and names which tradition holds which view. It does not argue that any one tradition is correct, and it is not affiliated with any church or denomination.

Partner link — we may be paid a fee at no cost to you, and it changes nothing about what we recommend. Details.

See a structured way to study

If a single passage was useful, a short study plan across a few weeks goes further without asking for a big commitment up front.

Build a study plan →
Free download

The Christian Traditions Compared: A Starter Guide

What Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant Christianity each teach, on the questions that actually divide them — free, no email spam.

Get the free guide →
Still stuck

Get in touch

There's no wrong way to ask — half-formed questions are welcome.